Black Box Telematics Device: Key Advantages and Challenges for Data Collection

While black-box policies are often aimed at young drivers, picking the right telematics data collection technology for your auto insurance programs can be an overwhelming task, but there are simple ways to narrow down your options. Start by evaluating these black box data collection advantages and challenges.

What is Black Box Car Insurance? An auto insurance black box is an electronic device that is professionally fitted/installed inside a vehicle to increase road safety and improve driving behavior. Once mounted, the black box captures and transmits driving behavior data over a cellular network to the data center enabling insurers to improve policyholder risk modeling, align insurance premiums and improve their relationship with policyholders.

In scenarios where maximum data accuracy is important while also ensuring the integrity the of data, black box solutions also known as ‘telematics’ or ‘pay as you go car insurance’ offer significant benefits. Black-box policies help insurers improve their loss ratio, better understand their policyholders and deliver new or better services to remain competitive. Additionally, black box technology offers benefits such as theft recovery and accident alerts, the table below explore the advantages and challenges of black-box data collection in more detail:

Delivers solid data collection accuracy: Because the black box is a fixed device mounted in the vehicle, vehicle identification, mileage tracking, and trip detection are uncontested. Consistent standardization of data across vehicles is another benefit. Requires professional installation: Because the black box must be installed by a third party professional, this option is less convenient for users, as compared to more portable devices, such as OBD and smartphone. Maintenance can also require a service appointment that customers must arrange.
Reduces tampering risks: In environments where vehicle theft is a problem or end users are inclined to circumvent the monitoring features, this solution provides reliable capabilities that are less likely to be compromised during operation. Theft recovery operations are also boosted by this technology. Raises user concerns: Some users may object to having what they consider an intrusive device installed in their vehicle. User concerns and objections about black boxes voiding warranties or interfering with the onboard computer must be addressed, as well as other myths.
Helps with claims remediation and improves loss ratio performance: By capturing rich, high-fidelity collision data, the black box solution captures vital information to aid in claims remediation,
resulting in improved loss ratio performance.
Represents a higher cost option: Ongoing support and maintenance for the black box, as well as the accrued installation expenses, boosts this option over the cost level of the other data collection technologies.



White Paper

Comparing Smartphone, Self-Powered, OBD, Black Box, and OEM Embedded Devices

Learn the pros and cons of telematics data collection technology for insurance telematics/UBI program planning.